Top 11 Best Smudge-Proof Mascaras For Oily Skin Of 2022

1. Best Hypoallergenic Formula: Secret Xpress 4D Silk Fiber EyeLash Mascara

This silky formula is a hypoallergenic mascara made with non-irritating ingredients, suitable for all skin types. It adds length and volume to the lashes, making them look fuller and more glamorous. The long-lasting formula lasts all day long without smudging or flaking, making it a great waterproof option for oily skin types. Pros

Smudge-proof Highly pigmented Waterproof No flaking and clumping

Cons

Might be difficult to remove

2. Best In Budget-Friendly: Maybelline Full ‘N Soft Waterproof Mascara

Get your hands on this budget-friendly waterproof mascara for full and healthy-looking eyelashes. The advanced formula is thick and deeply nourishes the lashes. Despite being nourishing, it does not trouble people with oily skin. Mascara lovers can expect to have clump-free, smooth lashes effortlessly with this product. Just swipe the brush from root to tip for an even application. Pro tip: Do not let the mascara dry between coats. Take a look at this video to learn more about the application of the Maybelline Full ‘N Soft Waterproof Mascara with a detailed review. Pros

No lash loss Nourishment of vitamin E Suitable for contact lens wearers Can be removed easily with an oil free makeup remover

Cons

Sensitive people might experience irritation

3. Best Natural Formula: EROINE MAKE Long and Curl Mascara Super Waterproof

When you use this mascara from Heroine Make, you are surely going to thank the Japanese for this product. Loaded with natural extracts like camellia oil, argan oil and royal jelly extract, this mascara offers much-needed nourishment to the lashes. Watch as this mascara offers long and curled eyelashes with just a few coats. Those with tiny lashes can keep them curled for long hours with this smudge-proof mascara. People with oily eyelids will love this product for its non-sticky coverage. Pros

Light-weight formula Waterproof mascara No smudging and clumping Easy to use

Cons

Some people might struggle to remove the mascara

4. Best Water-Proof Formula: Ellocy 2 in 1 4D Mascara

With this 2-in-1 4D Mascara, you bid goodbye to your falsies. After using this no-flake mascara, your eyelashes not only look fuller but also appear naturally fuller. The product comes with two brushes. The first one gives you a natural look while the second one adds volume to your lashes. The formula is waterproof and lasts all day. Pros

Hypoallergenic formula long-lasting Effortless application and removal Versatile product

Cons

Might dry slowly

5. Best Pigmented Mascara: stila Huge Extreme Lash Mascara

4.3 Image: Stila BUY ON AMAZON | $25 Elevate your glam routine with this highly pigmented smudge proof mascara for oily skin. It is a product that people with oily skin love. The product volumizes the lashes and gives intense black color within seconds. The soft, flexible bristles of this mascara brush separate the lashes and enhance their length. There are no clumps and flakes observed when using this mascara. Whether it is day or night, try coating your eyelashes with its triple-black pigmentation and mesmerize people with your dramatic lashes. Check out the honest review of the stila Huge Extreme Lash Mascara in this video. Pros

Premium quality Easy to wipe off excess product Cruelty-free Waterproof formula

Cons

Might become clumpy as the product dries out with time.

6. Best Washable: heimish Dailism Smudge Stop Mascara

The heimish Dailism Smudge Stop Mascara is a buildable mascara that defines and curls your lashes. The mascara contains vegetable wax and polymer that gives a hold to each lash to make them appear longer without the messy smudging. Although the mascara is waterproof and smudge-proof, it still can be easily removed with warm water. The curvy wand is suitable for easy application to make your eyes look wider without any clump or flaking. Pros

Waterproof Smudge-proof Easy to remove Small-tip wand for bottom lashes Does not flake

Cons

May not hold the definition for long

7. Best Conditioning Product: Grande Mascara

4.3 Image: Grande BUY ON AMAZON | $24.95 Grande Mascara is one that conditions while coating your eyelashes. It is loaded with peptides, panthenols and natural waxes that make your eyelashes look healthier and voluminous. Not only do these ingredients help your lash look fuller, but also condition them, making them smoother and softer. The mascara brush is a combination of hard and soft fibers to lift the lashes. This nourishing formula is the ideal choice for thick and clump-free lashes. Pros

Curls the eyelashes Smooth gliding formula Keeps the lashes soft and shiny Water-resistant formula

Cons

Brush might break off easily

8. Best Lengthening Formula: Clinique Lash Power Mascara Long-Wearing Formula

4.5 Image: Clinique BUY ON AMAZON | $23 Classy, long-lasting and smudge-free are the main features of this mascara. Clinique is known for its impressive line of products and this mascara is no different! The product offers long-lasting stay for up to 24 hours in any weather. This lengthening mascara is capable of lengthening even the tiniest of lashes, resulting in beautiful, voluminous lashes. The product is safe to use even for contact lens wearers. It surely is a must-have mascara for oily skin. Pros

Allergy-tested No sulfate formula Free from SLS and gluten Ophthalmologist tested

Cons

Less product quantity

9. Best For Oily Skin: Estee Lauder Double Wear Zero-Smudge Lengthening Mascara

4.5 Image: Estee Lauder BUY ON AMAZON | $25.88
This is a premium-quality product from a world-renowned brand. This mascara is one of the best ones out there for oily skin. Whether you are in hot and humid weather or experiencing perspiration, you must get your hands on this mascara to give your eyes that desired pop. It defines your lashes and keeps them clump-free for an entire day. Microfiber bristles used to design this mascara brush ease the application process and keep the lashes untangled for a smooth look. Pros

No smudge formula Prevents raccoon eyes Upwards of 15 hours of wear time Easy to remove

Cons

Thin brush, which some might not like

10. Best Sustainable: Blinc UltraVolume Tubing Mascara

The UltraVolume Tubing Mascara by Blinc is formulated for longer wear and volumizing false-lash effect and a semi-matte finish. The mascara is highly pigmented and has a buildable formula that gives your lashes lift and volume. This mascara comes with a super soft fiber wand that can help you achieve a full glam look with dramatic eyes. Pros

Clean ingredients Vegan Cruelty-free Long-lasting Water-resistant

Cons

Very thick formula

11. Best For Fallout Prevention: Laura Geller New York Extra Bold Mascara

4.1 Image: Laura Geller BUY ON AMAZON | $14.13 This is a perfect magic wand for your eyelashes. It works miraculously well and leaves the lashes highlighted. As the name suggests, the product offers a bold eye look and keeps up your makeup game together. The bristles are soft and flexible for easy application. Since the product is free from mineral oils, it serves as the perfect mascara for oily skin.  Pros

Great applicator Prevents fall outs Two types of bristles Good consistency of the product

Cons

The brush may take some getting used to

Choosing the right makeup products for oily skin can be a little tricky. Especially in the case of mascaras, as it keeps smudging and running. If you do not want your eyes to look like raccoon eyes, then there are some points that you must consider before purchasing mascaras. Here, we are providing a buying guide that can help you in making the right decision.

Factors To Be Considered While Buying Mascaras for Oily Skin

Ingredients

If you do not want your lashes to dry out then you must buy mascaras that contain coconut oil, jojoba oil, vitamin E, and non-irritating ingredients. Choose SPF-induced mascaras to keep your eyes free from harmful UV rays. Furthermore, the ideal choice for oily skin would be a mascara with microfiber. You must avoid mascaras that contain any sulfate formula, SLS, and gluten. Go for an ophthalmologist-tested mascara if you have persistent eye conditions.

Lasting Power

Mascaras with microfiber will help make your lashes appear thicker and they also last longer. It is because these mascaras contain a special kind of wax in their composition. You can also go with waterproof mascaras with non-drying formulas. Choose waterproof and smudge-proof mascaras that define your lashes without clumping or flaking.

Removable

It is suggested to buy mascaras that are easily removable. Usually waterproof mascaras are harder to remove and they can pull out your lashes while being removed. However, since oily skin requires formulations that would not be too greasy or melt away, you need to choose mascaras that can be removed but do not require frequent touch ups. So, normal mascaras could be the best choice only if they are transfer- and fade-proof.

Formula

If you are looking for a volume-boosting mascara, go with gentle formulations. Choose mascaras that offer a natural look without flaking, smudging, or clumping. In addition, many volume-boosting mascaras are ideal for oily skin and last all day long. If you are looking for lengthening mascaras, go with the ones that come with a precision brush to help visibly lengthen lashes.

Shades

Most oil-free mascaras come in a variety of colors such as black, brown, blue, and other vibrant shades. These colors are worth trying on and manage to suit anyone. For normal days, you can use black mascaras and for any special occasion, you can experiment with other colors. This was all from us about the top mascaras for oily skin. Hope this list is useful to you in choosing the best smudge proof mascara to give you luscious black eyelashes. Before buying any mascara make sure you read some tips given below to ensure a glam and gorgeous look.

How Do I Stop My Eyelids From Getting Oily

You can keep your eyelids from getting oily by following the below tips and tricks:

How Do You Avoid Getting Mascara On Your Eyelids?

Here are some quick tips that can help you avoid getting mascara on your eyelids:

Why Trust Stylecraze

The author of this article, Chaitra Krishnan, is a makeup fanatic. With her in-depth research on different makeup products, she always comes up with the best. She has curated the list of best mascaras for oily skin after extensive research and reading many online reviews from different forums. These mascaras are a perfect fit for oily skin. They are smudge-proof, long-lasting, and waterproof. Which is the best mascara for oily eyelids? The best mascara for oily eyelids is the one that is transfer-proof, smudge-proof, clump-free and long-lasting. One of the best mascaras for oily eyelids is Estee Lauder Double Wear Zero-Smudge Lengthening Mascara which lengthens your lashes and keeps the product only to your lashes, thus preventing raccoon eyes. Which is the best mascara that avoids smudging? There are quite a few best mascaras that don’t smudge. Products with long-lasting stay do not generally smudge. The list mentioned above has 11 options. Naming a few here- Clinique lash power mascara, Stila huge extreme mascara & Maybelline full ‘N soft waterproof mascara can be trusted for smudge free eyes. How do I stop mascara from smudging under my eyes? In order to stop your mascara from smudging under eyes use the following tricks- 1. Use a blotting paper to remove excess oil from under your eyes. 2. Set your makeup with a setting powder to keep away the stickiness. 3. Choose a smudge proof mascara. 4. Opt for a mascara that is thick in consistency, dries easily and is long-lasting. 5. Avoid creams in your under eye area. What is the best mascara for hooded eyes? Usually a curling and water resistant mascara is great for hooded eyes. Choose a long-lasting and water resistant formula like HEROINE MAKE long and curl mascara which keeps your eyes mess free. Also, it allows you to skip your eyelash curler which generally can be a hassle for people with hooded eyes. Is waterproof mascara better for oily skin? Yes. A waterproof mascara works better on oily skin as there is a possibility of the mascara getting smudged or coming off due to excessive oil. How do you keep mascara from smudging on oily skin? To avoid smudging or to mattify the finish, use a blotting paper or tissue to absorb the excess oil before applying eye makeup products.

Best Mascara For Straight Lashes Best Korean Mascaras For Beautiful And Long Lashes Best Lengthening Mascaras For Long, Fluttery Lashes Best Smudge-Proof Mascaras